Nonprofit Resources
Renewed Attack on Minister’s Housing Allowance
The Freedom From Religion Foundation and several employees filed a complaint, alleging that the housing allowance unconstitutionally violates the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment because it provides a tax benefit exclusively to religious individuals. A copy of the complaint is available on the ECFA website.
The Freedom From Religion Foundation had a previous case dismissed because it was not able to show that anyone was injured by this alleged discrimination. This time, the group has several employees who claimed a housing allowance, which the IRS denied. Now they have “injury,” because the employees pay more tax than a minister would pay.
The filing of the complaint is only the first step in what will probably be a several-year court proceeding. The U.S. government will file a response, defending the law. Briefs and motions will be filed, and the Federal District Court of the Western District will reach a decision. It will be appealed, regardless of who wins. More briefs and motions will be filed in the appellate court. In the last case, the time from initial filing to a decision by the appellate court was several years.
About the only sure thing right now is that ministers will be able to claim a housing allowance for 2016 under the existing tax law, and in future years unless and until case law or legislation changes.
We will provide updates as developments occur.
Sign up for e-news and alerts
1 Comment
At the risk of being unpopular, I believe the MHA should be subject to means testing and should only apply to those whose primary employer is a church. Televangelists and College Presidents do not help those of us who are defending this long held practice.